Monica的逻辑：存在AND门
graph TD
%% --- Define Styles (Color Palette) ---
classDef topEvent fill:#FFD1DC,stroke:#C70039,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef midEvent fill:#D6EAF8,stroke:#2E86C1,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef basicEvent fill:#D5F5E3,stroke:#28B463,stroke-width:1px,color:black;
classDef gate fill:#FCF3CF,stroke:#F1C40F,stroke-width:2px,shape:circle,color:black;
%% --- Nodes Definition ---
%% Top Event
Top["Top Event:<br/>Low Flow Detected<br/>by FIC10204"]:::topEvent
%% Level 1 Gates
Gate1(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 1 Intermediate Events
Path1["Path 1:<br/>Actual Flow Decrease"]:::midEvent
Path2["Path 2:<br/>Instrument False Alarm"]:::midEvent
%% Level 2 Gates
Gate2(("OR")):::gate
Gate3(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 2 Basic Events (Physical Failures)
Event1["Valve FCV10204<br/>Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event2["Pump P102A/B<br/>System Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event3["Pipeline<br/>Blockage"]:::basicEvent
%% Intermediate Event for Condensate
Event4["V-101 Condensate<br/>Insufficient"]:::midEvent
%% Level 3 Gate (CRITICAL: AND GATE)
GateAND{"AND"}:::gate
%% Level 3 Events
Cond1["Level Low<br/>(LT10158)"]:::basicEvent
Cond2["Process Causes<br/>for Low Level"]:::midEvent
%% Level 4 Gate
Gate4(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 4 Basic Events
Cause1["Feed Insufficient<br/>(XZV10102)"]:::basicEvent
Cause2["Excess Discharge<br/>(FCV10304)"]:::basicEvent
%% Instrument Branch Events
InstFail["Transmitter/Indicator<br/>Failure"]:::basicEvent
%% --- Connections ---
Top --> Gate1
Gate1 --> Path1
Gate1 --> Path2
Path1 --> Gate2
Gate2 --> Event1
Gate2 --> Event2
Gate2 --> Event3
Gate2 --> Event4
Event4 --> GateAND
GateAND --> Cond1
GateAND --> Cond2
Cond2 --> Gate4
Gate4 --> Cause1
Gate4 --> Cause2
Path2 --> Gate3
Gate3 --> InstFail
豆包的逻辑：全都是OR门
graph TD
%% --- Define Styles (Color Palette) ---
classDef topEvent fill:#FFD1DC,stroke:#C70039,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef midEvent fill:#D6EAF8,stroke:#2E86C1,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef basicEvent fill:#D5F5E3,stroke:#28B463,stroke-width:1px,color:black;
classDef gate fill:#FCF3CF,stroke:#F1C40F,stroke-width:2px,shape:circle,color:black;
%% --- Nodes Definition (修正逻辑冗余和事件定位) ---
%% Top Event（不变）
Top["Top Event:<br/>Low Flow Detected<br/>by FIC10204"]:::topEvent
%% Level 1 Gates（不变）
Gate1(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 1 Intermediate Events（不变）
Path1["Path 1:<br/>Actual Flow Decrease"]:::midEvent
Path2["Path 2:<br/>Instrument False Alarm"]:::midEvent
%% Level 2 Gates（删除Path2的冗余Gate3）
Gate2(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 2 Basic Events (Physical Failures)（不变）
Event1["Valve FCV10204<br/>Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event2["Pump P102A/B<br/>System Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event3["Pipeline<br/>Blockage"]:::basicEvent
%% 修正：合并重复事件，Event4直接定义为“液位低”，删除冗余的Cond1
Event4["V-101 Condensate<br/>Level Low (LT10158)"]:::midEvent
%% 修正：删除错误的AND门，直接用OR门拆解Event4的工艺原因
Gate4(("OR")):::gate
%% Level 4 Basic Events（不变，直接作为Event4的工艺原因）
Cause1["Feed Insufficient<br/>(XZV10102)"]:::basicEvent
Cause2["Excess Discharge<br/>(FCV10304)"]:::basicEvent
%% Instrument Branch Events（不变，直接关联Path2）
InstFail["Transmitter/Indicator<br/>Failure"]:::basicEvent
%% --- Connections（修正逻辑流向，删除冗余路径） ---
Top --> Gate1
Gate1 --> Path1
Gate1 --> Path2
%% 实际流量下降路径：OR门涵盖所有物理原因
Path1 --> Gate2
Gate2 --> Event1
Gate2 --> Event2
Gate2 --> Event3
Gate2 --> Event4
%% 冷凝水液位低的工艺原因：直接用OR门拆解，无需AND门
Event4 --> Gate4
Gate4 --> Cause1
Gate4 --> Cause2
%% 仪表误报警路径：删除冗余OR门，直接关联故障事件
Path2 --> InstFail
Deepseek：判定两者对错
graph TD
%% --- 定义样式 ---
classDef topEvent fill:#FFD1DC,stroke:#C70039,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef midEvent fill:#D6EAF8,stroke:#2E86C1,stroke-width:2px,color:black;
classDef basicEvent fill:#D5F5E3,stroke:#28B463,stroke-width:1px,color:black;
classDef gate fill:#FCF3CF,stroke:#F1C40F,stroke-width:2px,shape:circle,color:black;
%% --- 节点定义 ---
%% 顶事件（Top Event）
Top["Top Event:<br/>Low Flow Detected by FIC10204"]:::topEvent
%% 第一层逻辑门：OR gate
Gate1(("OR")):::gate
%% 中间事件：实际流量降低（Actual Flow Decrease）和仪表误报（Instrument False Alarm）
Path1["Actual Flow Decrease"]:::midEvent
Path2["Instrument False Alarm"]:::midEvent
%% 实际流量降低路径的 OR gate
Gate2(("OR")):::gate
%% 基本事件：阀门故障、泵故障、管道堵塞
Event1["Valve FCV10204 Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event2["Pump P102A/B System Failure"]:::basicEvent
Event3["Pipeline Blockage"]:::basicEvent
%% 中间事件：冷凝水产量不足（V-101 Condensate Insufficient）
Event4["V-101 Condensate Insufficient"]:::midEvent
%% AND gate：用于冷凝水产量不足，需同时满足液位过低和工艺原因
GateAND{"AND"}:::gate
%% 子事件：液位过低（Level Low）和工艺原因（Process Causes for Low Level）
Cond1["Level Low (LT10158)"]:::basicEvent
Cond2["Process Causes for Low Level"]:::midEvent
%% OR gate：工艺原因的具体原因
Gate4(("OR")):::gate
%% 基本事件：进料不足和排放过量
Cause1["Feed Insufficient (XZV10102)"]:::basicEvent
Cause2["Excess Discharge (FCV10304)"]:::basicEvent
%% 仪表误报路径的 OR gate
Gate3(("OR")):::gate
%% 基本事件：传感器探头故障和控制器故障
InstFail1["Sensor Probe (FT10204) Contamination/Damage"]:::basicEvent
InstFail2["Controller (FIC10204) Internal Fault/Calibration Drift"]:::basicEvent
%% --- 连接关系 ---
Top --> Gate1
Gate1 --> Path1
Gate1 --> Path2
%% 实际流量降低路径
Path1 --> Gate2
Gate2 --> Event1
Gate2 --> Event2
Gate2 --> Event3
Gate2 --> Event4
%% 冷凝水产量不足的 AND 门结构
Event4 --> GateAND
GateAND --> Cond1
GateAND --> Cond2
%% 工艺原因的 OR 门结构
Cond2 --> Gate4
Gate4 --> Cause1
Gate4 --> Cause2
%% 仪表误报路径
Path2 --> Gate3
Gate3 --> InstFail1
Gate3 --> InstFail2
0 条评论